The iliad was written by homer, the movie troy was done by hollywood and things were taken out of context. The ancient legend of troy, recorded in homers epic poem the iliad oxford trans. The illiad primary source of trojan war in the modern vulgate the standard accepted version, the iliad contains 15,693 lines. What role do the gods play in the iliad and the odyssey. The heel being his only vulnerable point, achilles comes to an end. Meneleuss death, pariss escape, helens situation, and the trojan princesses. James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. Apr 06, 2008 what are differences between the iliad and the movie troy. The iliad begins in the 9th twelvemonth of the 10 twelvemonth besieging of the greeks upon troy. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. Paris shoots an arrow at achilles heel to kill him.
Agamemnon is inspired to attack troy by a dream sent by the gods, who want to bring his army misery for taking briseis away from achilles. From babylon to america, the prophecy movie by school for prophets attila kakarott duration. While on the other hand, the book onset is narrowed down to the ninth year. Comparison of iliad book and troy film freebooksummary. Character similarities and differances character similarities. The reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Comparison of the iliad, the odyssey, and the aeneid. The movie troy written by david benioff and directed by wolfgang petersen was inspired by the iliad, an ancient greek poem about the time of warrior achilles argument with king agamemnon during the trojan war. Similarities and differences between the iliad and the movie troy 1057 words 5 pages logan k. In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy. The differences between the book iliad and the movie troy. The film troy is a movie released in 2004 and was directed by wolfgang petersen, and has been influenced by the classical epic poem, the iliad which has been credited of the greek poet homer. Major differences between the homers iliad and the film troy.
The similarities between achilles and hector is that both lived in the present moment and both wanted to achieve glory in order to be the hero that their homeland needed, while the differences include achilles being stubborn and angry while hector was prideful, yet cowardly and impulsive. The iliad and the odyssey analysis essay blog essayshark. Oct 14, 2012 the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. The coverage of the film starts all the way from why the trojangreeks conflict started up to the death of achilles and the fall of troy. Apr 14, 20 the fight between hector and achilles is told in different ways with the iliad and troy. Comparison between the epic poem the iliad and the film troy the modernday film troy that was released in 2004 was directed by wolfgang petersen, it was influenced by the epic poem, called the iliad which was written by the poet homer. One of the main things that achilles does in both texts is the killing of troys greatest warrior, hector. What are the differences between the movie troy and. The three major upsetting differences in troy compared to the iliad are the absence of the gods, the weak character and plot development, and the addition, exclusion, and reversal of key points.
A ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Discuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersons film troy with reference to what it has added to modern day society. Similarities between achilles and hector 1159 words. The fight between hector and achilles is told in different ways with the iliad and troy. Your browser does not currently recognize any of the video formats available. Achilles avenges hector for killing patroclus and aneus kills pallas in order to serve vengeance for turnus death. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the iliad, a work commonly. One uncanny resemblance is the similarity between the deaths of achilles and krishna. The main character that shows similarities in both the iliad and troy is achilles. Comparison between the aeneid and the iliad freebooksummary. One of the major differences between the two texts is the role of the greek gods.
In this lesson, well discuss the differences and similarities between homers the iliad and wolfgang petersens 2004 film troy. The purpose of this essay is to enhance our critical reading and writing skills. Grace sunny kang hist 151 october 10, 2017 comparison between the epic poem the iliad and the film troy the modernday film troy that was released in 2004 was directed by wolfgang petersen, it was influenced by the epic poem, called the iliad which was. Comparison of book iliad and the film troy achilles iliad scribd. The iliad verses troy i n the movie its stated that agamemnon brought the kings together for this war, which really isnt true. Differences between troy movie and the iliad essay example. The iliad begins in the ninth year of the ten year siege of the greeks upon troy, whereas the movie shows paris taking helen away from troy angering menelaus in the process. The film troy which is directed by wolfgang peterson has been deeply influenced by the epic poem, the iliad. Although most of the movie was on point according to the storyline and dialogues of the characters, there were still some major differences among the two. Screen adaptations of homers the iliad tend to focus on either the trojan war or the story of helen of troy.
In the movie troy, the characters such as achilles, agamemnon are presented in the same way as they are presented in the epic. This work is generally credited to the ancient greek poet named homer. The major similarities between the two would to me be, that achilles was a trojan. Although, there are many differences that i found between these two. Jul 24, 2017 homers iliad and wolfgang petersons troy are two different retellings of a myth that has been carried down for centuries. Oct 19, 2012 one of the major differences between the two texts is the role of the greek gods. What are some similarities and differences between the. Wolfgang peterson tackles the job of bringing the epic of homers the iliad to the big screen in his film troy. Differences between troy movie and iliad free essays.
Some major differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersens film troy, is that there was no mention of the gods being participants in the battle of troy. Homers poem the iliad is an epic poem that describes the majority of the war between greek and trojan. Examine the similarities and the differences between homers iliad and odyssey the iliad and the odyssey are ancient greek epic poems, traditionally ascribed to homer. Comparison paper on the book iliad and film troy on the plot the plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus. In homers iliad, the gods played a major part in the trojan war. Essay on comparison of troy and the iliad 883 words bartleby. Troy and iliad comparison by jessica peterson on prezi. Oct 14, 2012 a ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Odysseus convinced him to make a contract with the other suitors that made them promise. Between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences.
Comparison of book iliad and the film troy free download as word doc. Oct 16, 2012 some major differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersens film troy, is that there was no mention of the gods being participants in the battle of troy. Between the novel the iliad by homer and the movie troy directed by wolfgang peterson, there were mostly great similarities, yet there were also some strong differences. Odysseus convinced him to make a contract with the other suitors that made them promise that should anything. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the. There probably are just as many similarities as differences from the original. New haven sda temple brooklyn, ny recommended for you 2. Get an answer for what are the differences between the movie troy and the iiliad. Introduction aphrodite bribes paris into declaring her the winner of a beauty contest by promising him helen paris steals helen from menelaus triggers the trojan. Troy is a movie that first debuted in 2004 that was based on the epic, the iliad. Briseis is a trojan priestess and hectors cousin, captured during the attack on apollos temple.
Similarities between the iliad and the odyssey flashcards. Are there any similarities between the mahabharata and the. Both texts deal with the same subject, the siege of troy which was ended with the trickery of the wooden horse. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy essay sample. A ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. What similarities in achilles character in troy and iliad. Similarities and differences between troy and the iliad. The mean of this is essay is compare and contrast between achilles and hector discussing the similarities between two protagonists of the poem the iliad. Odyssey starts after the fall of troy, assumes the readers knowledge of events in the iliad, adds the the. Part three troy the iliad agamemnon did not do this in the book agamemnon brought the kings together for war the greeks won the war, and the trojan horse let them win. Analysis of similarities and differences between the poem iliad and its screen adaptation. While on the other hand, the book onset is narrowed down to.
Helen had many powerful suitors and her father was too afraid to pick one of them for her husband in fear of offending the others. Therefore, there are obvious deviations from the book such as the length of the trojan war, and the absence of celestial participation in the war. Differences between the iliad and the movie troy 854. Analysis and comparisoncharacterachilles 4classics20thirteen. Some events the film where taken straight from the iliad, and is at times the two stories are very similar to one another. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. The differences between the movie troy and the poem iliad and the explanation of why they occurred. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and.
However, in the movie troy the gods are barely even mentioned, and are only mentioned when referred to when signs are received. However there are several major differences between them, as troy. He is portrayed as a bloodthirsty coldblooded killer only wanting to fight to keep his name alive throughout the future generations. Within the iliad, the gods take sides within the trojan war and are seen fighting amongst the common soldiers. The mahabharata the mahabharata is the longest known epic poem and has been described as the longest poem ever w. There are many similarities that can be found between the iliad and the movie troy due to the fact the movie is based off the iliad. One of the most noticeable differences between the book and the movie is the absence of the gods. The iliad v troy comparsions between the modern film.
Discuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. This was a major plot point in homers iliad, as the gods who fought on the battlefield had somewhat of an influence on the outcome of each battle and eventually the outcome of the war. Between the book and the film there are a wealth of differences, and similarities only lie in the basic, undisputed ideas. Oct 14, 2012 character similarities and differances character similarities. Iliad and troy comparison the portrayal of the relationship between helen and paris sammy t. The differant storylines between troy and the iliad. Similarities and differences between the iliad and the movie troy 1057 words 5 pages. A comparsion between the epic poem the iliad and the modern film troy the film troy is a movie released in 2004 and was directed by wolfgang petersen, and has been influenced by the classical epic poem, the iliad which has been credited of the greek poet homer. Robert fitzgerald university press 1974 has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy 2004, wolfgang peterson. In this blog im going to show the differences of the battle between the great fighters. On the other hand, there are significant differences between the movie and the epic. The film also omits a lot of characters and subplots from the iliad. Similarities between the iliad and troy since the film troy is based off the iliad, obviously there are many. Similarities and differences between hector and achilles.
Sep 15, 20 from babylon to america, the prophecy movie by school for prophets attila kakarott duration. Comparison and contrast between achilles and hector. Apr 18, 20 the similarities between peterson and homers achilles are numerous, in both texts, he is a fearsome warrior with a godlike reputation on the battle field. The iliad v troy comparsions between the modern film troy. Viewers should note the difference between faithful adaptations and loosely inspired.
The iliad begins in the ninth year of the ten year siege of the greeks upon troy, whereas the movie shows paris taking helen away from troy angering menelaus. Well learn about the characters in each version and how the. Throughout the lesson, well talk about the similarities and differences between. Iliad being a lengthy text, it is impossible to include every detail in a movie. The are many similarities and many difference, in the iliad by homer and the movie troy, for achilles character. First and most disappointing, was the absence of the gods in the movie troy.
Similarities and differences between the iliad and the. Both the film and the poem have the same ending plots, such as the blockade of troy by the greeks, the. The differences consisting of hector running away from achilles in the iliad and a long and glorious battle between them both in the movie troy. Start studying similarities between the iliad and the odyssey. Differences between the iliad and the movie troy 854 words. Comparing troy with the iliad asian university for. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the iliad, a work commonly credited to. The movie brings to a modern audience the admirations of grecian history. Both the film and the poem have the same ending plots, such as the blockade of troy. Both texts deal with the same subject, the siege of troy which was ended with the trickery of the wooden. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the iliad, a work commonly credited to the ancient greek poet homer. Homers iliad and wolfgang petersons troy are two different retellings of a myth that has been carried down for centuries. The iliad begins in the ninth year of the ten year siege of the greeks upon troy, whereas the movie shows paris taking helen away from.
920 680 857 392 1409 800 290 578 735 380 1034 1263 1506 1598 980 1208 438 272 1451 56 165 605 954 689 1341 462 335 372 1307 1542 1270 170 1226 987 1316 1544 1507 245 231 968 1412 543 1457 243 1226